Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Half a year back or so I built a mini SaaS product that failed, now I'm in the process of open sourcing it so that everybody can freely host it for themselves. Here's the project homepage https://magiclogin.net, it was/is transactional e-mails and e-mail authentication as a service.

Getting it ready for open sourcing is a lot more work than I anticipated, I don't want to just dump it in a Github repo and have nobody be able to actually use it, so I'm making deployment easier and writing docs on how to run it yourself.

I didn't build the project to make money necessarily, it was mostly a learning project. That doesn't mean that I didn't hope it would be at least moderately succesful financially. But it was a case of "build and they won't come" and my other projects took off much more so I couldn't justify trying to market/pivot it. The final nail in the coffin came when I received a cease and desist letter because apparently a vc-funded auth provider trademarked the term "Magic Login".. So yeah..



Hi, I think it is great that you are making the effort to open source your project. I did the same with a real estate website builder I created:

https://github.com/etewiah/property_web_builder

It was a lot of work but I now have a small stream of people who contact me every so often about it.

BTW, you seem like a smart guy and I am looking for someone to work with me on a relaunch of the project as a paid product. I have learnt a lot in the years since my first attempt so I think I have a pretty decent chance of success this time round.


This is pretty useful as a product, and magic.link has been a hit and miss experience for me. Where will you post/announce the open source version? I’ll definitely check it out!


I'm not sure yet - but for sure I'll post a link up on https://magiclogin.net (or you could follow me on Github, username @gzuidhof)


That seems really neat! Have you considered just relaunching it under a different name?


This is interesting. I’m building something that is similar. What do you think it didn’t succeed? Not enough marketing? Difficult implementation?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: