Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

How much does the author actually know about a heroin addiction? I mean, I don't have one, but I've talked to people that do, and a lot of the problems with heroin are because we made it illegal and hard to get. If we sold it for a dollar at every gas station we wouldn't have nearlythe same problems with it we do today. And besides no one sells heroin anymore, everyone has moved on to fentanyl.




Widespread heroin addiction might cut military spending but would not be cheaper for health services.

Sure, in its clean form it won't kill you quickly, but it is a horrendously addictive depressant with significant medium-term and severe long-term neurological and physiological effects that would in themselves cause poverty through loss of work even if it was as cheap to buy as it is to produce.

It should remain a decriminalised controlled substance and every effort should be spent trying to stop people ever starting to take it — the Portuguese strategy. Not least because if it's cheap and freely available, many, many people will overdose on it.


Spot on. It (Heroin) will eventually bugger your liver, but with a clean supply you get 20-30 years.

This is an unpopular opinion here, I won’t give my theory as to why, but people seem to imagine that drugs being illegal is the main barrier preventing the proletariat from using them and we’d all be rushing to the heroin store the second it became available.

That’s the addiction talking. Of course they want it, and easy. Once you have it, you’ll forever want it. It’s like that.

You aren't providing any counterargument. You're just repeating the narrative: one taste and you're an addict forever!

https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapsychiatry/fullarticle/...

I’m not saying they don’t need help. They absolutely do. I definitely not for legalizing it.

I had a childhood friend spend a decade in federal prison over it.


He uses heroin as a metaphor. Do you know metaphors shouldn't be taken in very precise details, right?

> If we sold it for a dollar at every gas station we wouldn't have nearlythe same problems with it we do today.

Go to Portugal. Heroin consumption is legalized there. And it isn't a pretty sight.


Heroin consumption isn't legalized here, it is decriminalized.

Also, it was MUCH worse when it was a crime.


Well, I will love to go to Portugal someday, but for now I used the internet, and found out that since Portugal decriminalized heroin, its drug usage has fallen below EU average:

https://transformdrugs.org/blog/drug-decriminalisation-in-po...


It's complicated. Portugal had a huge problem before it was made "legal", too. (It's not exactly legal.)

Look at drug overdose deaths for instance.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drug_policy_of_Portugal




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: